Security dilemma

Securing a church facility which includes daycare and school ministries is extra challenging in our times. Daycares and schools across the country have increased security in light of Columbine and the other tragedies that have occurred over the past decade. It's not uncommon to find such facilities in a lock-down mode with no open access to the public. In a day when we have to anticipate minors not responding to conflict appropriately, when we have to anticipate child-custody issues, when we have to acknowledge the sensitivity of private information in the information age... all things that are inherent with daycare/school ministries.

At the same time, churches have played a safe-haven role in the community... a place where anyone can go for help, a place were anyone can seek, to a certain extent, asylum, a place worshippers call their church and can go anytime.

It seems these two paths are on a collision course, if they haven't collided already. At Grace we introduced new daytime security measures last spring and we're hoping to introduce further improvements in the next month or so. Our biggest dilemma has been trying to navigate these two forces: the security needs of our daycare/school ministry and the open-access needs of the church.

We had reached a concept of keeping the main lobby an open access area, meanwhile isolating it from the rest of the facility. The downside to the concept is that it would create obstructions in the main hallway, obstructions that I fear would negatively impact people flow on Sundays. The traffic flow on Sundays is of great concern to me. We have a lot of people moving about our building between services and I find it challenging to get from one end of the building to another - it's like the Christmas shopping season, it's so crowded. Putting doors across our main hallway just doesn't seem like a good idea with the volume we already have.

But not to obstruct the hallway means that open-access to the building will be sacrificed. I don't like that, but I'm struggling to find another solution. Instead of being able to walk in the church doors, the entrance will be monitored with a intercom/bell-type system where the receptionist will have to buzz people in. Remember, this is for business hours only. On Sundays the doors would all be open.

That's where my thinking is right now. It's a dilemma. I'm torn between giving up the open-access and obstructing the hallway traffic flow.